• Mehr als 3 Millionen Wörter Inhalt
  • |
  • in**@********aw.com
  • |
  • Tel: 03322 5078053
Rechtsanwalt Marian Härtel - ITMediaLaw

No products in the cart.

  • en English
  • de Deutsch
  • Informationen
    • Ideal partner
    • About lawyer Marian Härtel
    • Quick and flexible access
    • Principles as a lawyer
    • Why a lawyer and business consultant?
    • Focus areas of attorney Marian Härtel
      • Focus on start-ups
      • Investment advice
      • Corporate law
      • Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain and Games
      • AI and SaaS
      • Streamers and influencers
      • Games and esports law
      • IT/IP Law
      • Law firm for GMBH,UG, GbR
      • Law firm for IT/IP and media law
    • The everyday life of an IT lawyer
    • How can I help clients?
    • Testimonials
    • Team: Saskia Härtel – WHO AM I?
    • Agile and lean law firm
    • Price overview
    • Various information
      • Terms
      • Privacy policy
      • Imprint
  • Services
    • Support and advice of agencies
    • Contract review and preparation
    • Games law consulting
    • Consulting for influencers and streamers
    • Advice in e-commerce
    • DLT and Blockchain consulting
    • Legal advice in corporate law: from incorporation to structuring
    • Legal compliance and expert opinions
    • Outsourcing – for companies or law firms
    • Booking as speaker
  • News
    • Gloss / Opinion
    • Law on the Internet
    • Online retail
    • Law and computer games
    • Law and Esport
    • Blockchain and web law
    • Data protection Law
    • Copyright
    • Labour law
    • Competition law
    • Corporate
    • EU law
    • Law on the protection of minors
    • Tax
    • Other
    • Internally
  • Podcast
    • ITMediaLaw Podcast
  • Knowledge base
    • Laws
    • Legal terms
    • Contract types
    • Clause types
    • Forms of financing
    • Legal means
    • Authorities
    • Company forms
    • Tax
    • Concepts
  • Videos
    • Information videos – about Marian Härtel
    • Videos – about me (Couch)
    • Blogpost – individual videos
    • Videos on services
    • Shorts
    • Podcast format
    • Third-party videos
    • Other videos
  • Contact
Kurzberatung
  • Informationen
    • Ideal partner
    • About lawyer Marian Härtel
    • Quick and flexible access
    • Principles as a lawyer
    • Why a lawyer and business consultant?
    • Focus areas of attorney Marian Härtel
      • Focus on start-ups
      • Investment advice
      • Corporate law
      • Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain and Games
      • AI and SaaS
      • Streamers and influencers
      • Games and esports law
      • IT/IP Law
      • Law firm for GMBH,UG, GbR
      • Law firm for IT/IP and media law
    • The everyday life of an IT lawyer
    • How can I help clients?
    • Testimonials
    • Team: Saskia Härtel – WHO AM I?
    • Agile and lean law firm
    • Price overview
    • Various information
      • Terms
      • Privacy policy
      • Imprint
  • Services
    • Support and advice of agencies
    • Contract review and preparation
    • Games law consulting
    • Consulting for influencers and streamers
    • Advice in e-commerce
    • DLT and Blockchain consulting
    • Legal advice in corporate law: from incorporation to structuring
    • Legal compliance and expert opinions
    • Outsourcing – for companies or law firms
    • Booking as speaker
  • News
    • Gloss / Opinion
    • Law on the Internet
    • Online retail
    • Law and computer games
    • Law and Esport
    • Blockchain and web law
    • Data protection Law
    • Copyright
    • Labour law
    • Competition law
    • Corporate
    • EU law
    • Law on the protection of minors
    • Tax
    • Other
    • Internally
  • Podcast
    • ITMediaLaw Podcast
  • Knowledge base
    • Laws
    • Legal terms
    • Contract types
    • Clause types
    • Forms of financing
    • Legal means
    • Authorities
    • Company forms
    • Tax
    • Concepts
  • Videos
    • Information videos – about Marian Härtel
    • Videos – about me (Couch)
    • Blogpost – individual videos
    • Videos on services
    • Shorts
    • Podcast format
    • Third-party videos
    • Other videos
  • Contact
Rechtsanwalt Marian Härtel - ITMediaLaw

Rechtsanwalt Marian Härtel - ITMediaLaw > Law on the Internet > Amazon merchant not responsible for user comments

Amazon merchant not responsible for user comments

7. November 2022
in Law on the Internet, Online retail
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0 0
A A
0
amazon logo 500500
Key Facts
  • The First Civil Senate of the Federal Court of Justice ruled that online retailers are not liable for customer reviews.
  • The defendant sells kinesiology tapes whose pain-relieving effect has not been medically proven.
  • Customer reviews on Amazon are misleading, but the defendant did not actively advertise them.
  • The judges confirmed that the defendant was not liable under competition law for the reviews of third parties.
  • Customer reviews enjoy constitutional protection as part of freedom of expression.
  • The consumer's interest in exchanging information about products is protected by Article 5 of the Basic Law.
  • No indication of health risk with kinesiology tapes; therefore no assessment was necessary.

The I. Civil Senate of the Federal Court of Justice, which is responsible among other things for claims arising from the UWG, has ruled that an online retailer is generally not liable under competition law for reviews of a product by customers.

Content Hide
1. Facts of the case:
2. Process to date:
3. Decision of the Federal Court of Justice:
3.1. Author: Marian Härtel

Facts of the case:

The plaintiff is a registered competition association. The defendant sells kinesiology tapes. In the past, it has advertised these products as suitable for pain treatment, which is not medically proven. The defendant therefore issued a cease-and-desist declaration to the plaintiff on November 4, 2013, subject to a penalty.

The defendant also offers its products on the online trading platform Amazon. There, for each product, an ASIN assigned to this product is generated via the EAN, which is intended to ensure that when a specific product is called up, the offers of all suppliers of this product are displayed. As is known, buyers can rate the products. Amazon assigns such a rating to the product listed under the corresponding ASIN without further examination. As a result, an item displays all customer reviews that have been submitted for that product, which may be offered by multiple sellers.

On January 17, 2017, the defendant offered kinesiology tapes on Amazon. Under this offer, customer reviews were available, which included the references “pain-relieving tape!”, “This product is perfect for pain…”, “Quickly the pain subsides”, “Relief of pain is noticeable”, “The pain goes away by taping ” and “Rel ieve pain”. The plaintiff demanded payment of a contractual penalty from the defendant. Amazon refused to delete the customer reviews at the defendant’s request.

The plaintiff is seeking an injunction and payment of the contractual penalty and the warning costs. The defendant had adopted the customer reviews and should have worked towards their deletion. If this was not possible, it would not be allowed to offer the products on Amazon

Process to date:

The landgericht dismissed the action. There is no claim aim of Paragraph 8(8) of the 1, Section 3a UWG in conjunction with Section 11 para. 1 Sentence 1 No 11 HWG. The plaintiff’s appeal was unsuccessful. It is true that the health claims contained in the customer reviews are misleading. But they were not advertising. At the very least, such advertising would not be attributable to the defendant.

Decision of the Federal Court of Justice:

The Federal Court of Justice dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal. The Court of Appeal was right to assume that the defendant was not liable under competition law for customer reviews of the products it offered on Amazon.

The plaintiff’s right to injunctive relief does not arise from Section 11 (1) of the German Civil Code. 1 sentence 1 no. 11 and sentence 2 HWG, which prohibits advertising for medical devices with misleading statements by third parties. The customer reviews are admittedly misleading statements by third parties, because the claimed pain relief by kinesiology tapes is not medically verifiable. However, the defendant had not advertised with the customer reviews. According to the findings of the Court of Appeal, which were free of any legal errors, it had neither actively advertised with the reviews itself nor had it initiated them, nor had it adopted the customer reviews as its own by assuming responsibility for their content. Rather, the customer reviews are marked as such, can be found on Amazon separately from the defendant’s offer and would not be attributed by the users to the sphere of the defendant as seller.

The defendant would also not be under a legal obligation to prevent the customer reviews from being misleading pursuant to § 5 para. 1 sentence 1 and 2 case 2 no. 1 UWG. Their offer on Amazon does not constitute a guarantee position. It is of crucial importance that customer rating systems on online marketplaces are socially desirable and enjoy constitutional protection. The interest of consumers to comment on products and to inform themselves or exchange views on the characteristics, advantages and disadvantages of a product from various sources, which also include reviews by other customers, before making a purchase, is protected by the fundamental right of freedom of opinion and information of Art. 5 Para. 1 sentence 1 GG. According to the Federal Court of Justice, there is no need to weigh this against the legal interest of public health, which as a community good of high rank could justify an encroachment on this fundamental right, because there are no indications of a health hazard in the offer of kinesiology tapes.

Marian Härtel
Author: Marian Härtel

Marian Härtel ist Rechtsanwalt und Fachanwalt für IT-Recht mit einer über 25-jährigen Erfahrung als Unternehmer und Berater in den Bereichen Games, E-Sport, Blockchain, SaaS und Künstliche Intelligenz. Seine Beratungsschwerpunkte umfassen neben dem IT-Recht insbesondere das Urheberrecht, Medienrecht sowie Wettbewerbsrecht. Er betreut schwerpunktmäßig Start-ups, Agenturen und Influencer, die er in strategischen Fragen, komplexen Vertragsangelegenheiten sowie bei Investitionsprojekten begleitet. Dabei zeichnet sich seine Beratung durch einen interdisziplinären Ansatz aus, der juristische Expertise und langjährige unternehmerische Erfahrung miteinander verbindet. Ziel seiner Tätigkeit ist stets, Mandanten praxisorientierte Lösungen anzubieten und rechtlich fundierte Unterstützung bei der Umsetzung innovativer Geschäftsmodelle zu gewährleisten.

Tags: AmazonBghCompetition lawConsumerContractual penaltyDeclaration of injunctionFederal courtHaftungInformationInjunctive reliefKILawsuit

Weitere spannende Blogposts

Agile law firm: How lean structures and modern technologies are changing the legal profession

Agile law firm: How lean structures and modern technologies are changing the legal profession
11. May 2023

Lean and Flexible: The Foundation of My Modern Law Firm At a time when the pace of our world is...

Read moreDetails

Information requirements for SaaS providers: Blockchain and AI in a legal context

informationspflichten fuer saas anbieter blockchain und ki im rechtlichen kontext
13. August 2023

Competition law Competition law, a fundamental pillar of economic law, was created to ensure balanced and fair competition between market...

Read moreDetails

Advertising labeling for influencers soon only with real consideration?

Advertising labeling for influencers soon only with real consideration?
7. November 2022

One of the biggest topics here on the blog is certainly the question of when influencers, streamers, etc. have to...

Read moreDetails

ECJ overturns Privacy Shield: review contracts!

District Court Frankfurt a.M. on the right to be forgotten
7. November 2022

The General Data Protection Regulation(GDPR) stipulates that personal data may in principle only be transferred to a third country if...

Read moreDetails

Bundeskartellamt and ratings on the Internet

Bundeskartellamt and ratings on the Internet
7. November 2022

The German Federal Cartel Office has launched a sector inquiry into user ratings on the Internet. Research and media reports...

Read moreDetails

Video: Contracts are for making up

YouTube: What to do about copyright extortion?
7. November 2022

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=185qxDcPeVQ   My video today on "Contracts are for contracting!" or "Why streamers should also work with written contracts when...

Read moreDetails

Attention craftsmen and service providers: Unresolved consumer revocation – a long-term consequence without value replacement!

Attention craftsmen and service providers: Unresolved consumer revocation – a long-term consequence without value replacement!
25. May 2023

Note on the long withdrawal period: In the absence of information, it can be up to 1 year and 14...

Read moreDetails

Esport: What belongs in a player contract?

Cologne District Court considers online contract generator to be illegal
7. November 2022

On the subject of player contracts, I have already written a great many here on the blog, e.g. on the...

Read moreDetails

Commercial agents are agents within the meaning of the UWG

Transfer sums in esport?
7. November 2022

Many companies make use of sales representatives, in one form or another, sometimes obviously (see the well-known vacuum cleaner sales...

Read moreDetails
e0c1c4f3 5ebb 4781 ae38 575fa47f2696 202348477

Declaration of intent

29. March 2025

Definition and meaning of the declaration of intent The declaration of intent is a central element of every legal transaction...

Read moreDetails
Bootstrapping

Bootstrapping

27. June 2023
Research Collaboration Agreement

Research Collaboration Agreement

16. October 2024
SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity)

SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity)

16. October 2024
Provider liability

Limitation of liability in contracts

11. April 2025

Podcast Folgen

eda7ba83 c559 4e68 8441 41159a0751f3

Blitzskalierung und rechtliche Herausforderungen: Der Balanceakt für Startups

20. April 2025

In dieser Episode sprechen Anna und Max über die rechtlichen Herausforderungen von Blitzskalierung und disruptiven Geschäftsmodellen. Am Beispiel von Plattformen...

Startups und Innovation in Deutschland – Herausforderungen und Chancen

Startups und Innovation in Deutschland – Herausforderungen und Chancen

25. September 2024

In dieser aufschlussreichen Podcast-Episode wird ein tiefgreifender Blick auf die Startup- und Innovationslandschaft in Deutschland und Europa geworfen. Die Diskussion...

8315f1ef298eb54dfeed2f5e55c8b9da 1

Erste Testfolge des ITMediaLaw Podcast

26. August 2024

Erste TestfolgeLiebe Leserinnen und Leser,ich freue mich, heute den ersten Testlauf unseres brandneuen IT Media Law Podcasts zu präsentieren! In diesem Podcast...

Influencer und Gaming: Rechtliche Herausforderungen in der digitalen Unterhaltungswelt

Influencer und Gaming: Rechtliche Herausforderungen in der digitalen Unterhaltungswelt

25. September 2024

In dieser fesselnden Folge nimmt Rechtsanwalt Marian Härtel die Zuhörer mit auf eine spannende Reise durch die dynamische Welt der...

  • Privacy policy
  • Imprint
  • Contact
  • About lawyer Marian Härtel
Marian Härtel, Rathenaustr. 58a, 14612 Falkensee, info@itmedialaw.com

Marian Härtel - Rechtsanwalt für IT-Recht, Medienrecht und Startups, mit einem Fokus auf innovative Geschäftsmodelle, Games, KI und Finanzierungsberatung.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
  • Informationen
    • Ideal partner
    • About lawyer Marian Härtel
    • Quick and flexible access
    • Principles as a lawyer
    • Why a lawyer and business consultant?
    • Focus areas of attorney Marian Härtel
      • Focus on start-ups
      • Investment advice
      • Corporate law
      • Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain and Games
      • AI and SaaS
      • Streamers and influencers
      • Games and esports law
      • IT/IP Law
      • Law firm for GMBH,UG, GbR
      • Law firm for IT/IP and media law
    • The everyday life of an IT lawyer
    • How can I help clients?
    • Testimonials
    • Team: Saskia Härtel – WHO AM I?
    • Agile and lean law firm
    • Price overview
    • Various information
      • Terms
      • Privacy policy
      • Imprint
  • Services
    • Support and advice of agencies
    • Contract review and preparation
    • Games law consulting
    • Consulting for influencers and streamers
    • Advice in e-commerce
    • DLT and Blockchain consulting
    • Legal advice in corporate law: from incorporation to structuring
    • Legal compliance and expert opinions
    • Outsourcing – for companies or law firms
    • Booking as speaker
  • News
    • Gloss / Opinion
    • Law on the Internet
    • Online retail
    • Law and computer games
    • Law and Esport
    • Blockchain and web law
    • Data protection Law
    • Copyright
    • Labour law
    • Competition law
    • Corporate
    • EU law
    • Law on the protection of minors
    • Tax
    • Other
    • Internally
  • Podcast
    • ITMediaLaw Podcast
  • Knowledge base
    • Laws
    • Legal terms
    • Contract types
    • Clause types
    • Forms of financing
    • Legal means
    • Authorities
    • Company forms
    • Tax
    • Concepts
  • Videos
    • Information videos – about Marian Härtel
    • Videos – about me (Couch)
    • Blogpost – individual videos
    • Videos on services
    • Shorts
    • Podcast format
    • Third-party videos
    • Other videos
  • Contact
  • en English
  • de Deutsch
Kostenlose Kurzberatung