• Mehr als 3 Millionen Wörter Inhalt
  • |
  • info@itmedialaw.com
  • |
  • Tel: 03322 5078053
Rechtsanwalt Marian Härtel - ITMediaLaw

No products in the cart.

  • en English
  • de Deutsch
  • Informationen
    • Ideal partner
    • About lawyer Marian Härtel
    • Quick and flexible access
    • Principles as a lawyer
    • Why a lawyer and business consultant?
    • Focus areas of attorney Marian Härtel
      • Focus on start-ups
      • Investment advice
      • Corporate law
      • Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain and Games
      • AI and SaaS
      • Streamers and influencers
      • Games and esports law
      • IT/IP Law
      • Law firm for GMBH,UG, GbR
      • Law firm for IT/IP and media law
    • The everyday life of an IT lawyer
    • How can I help clients?
    • Testimonials
    • Team: Saskia Härtel – WHO AM I?
    • Agile and lean law firm
    • Price overview
    • Various information
      • Terms
      • Privacy policy
      • Imprint
  • Services
    • Support and advice of agencies
    • Contract review and preparation
    • Games law consulting
    • Consulting for influencers and streamers
    • Advice in e-commerce
    • DLT and Blockchain consulting
    • Legal advice in corporate law: from incorporation to structuring
    • Legal compliance and expert opinions
    • Outsourcing – for companies or law firms
    • Booking as speaker
  • News
    • Gloss / Opinion
    • Law on the Internet
    • Online retail
    • Law and computer games
    • Law and Esport
    • Blockchain and web law
    • Data protection Law
    • Copyright
    • Labour law
    • Competition law
    • Corporate
    • EU law
    • Law on the protection of minors
    • Tax
    • Other
    • Internally
  • Podcast
    • ITMediaLaw Podcast
  • Knowledge base
    • Laws
    • Legal terms
    • Contract types
    • Clause types
    • Forms of financing
    • Legal means
    • Authorities
    • Company forms
    • Tax
    • Concepts
  • Videos
    • Information videos – about Marian Härtel
    • Videos – about me (Couch)
    • Blogpost – individual videos
    • Videos on services
    • Shorts
    • Podcast format
    • Third-party videos
    • Other videos
  • Contact
Kurzberatung
  • Informationen
    • Ideal partner
    • About lawyer Marian Härtel
    • Quick and flexible access
    • Principles as a lawyer
    • Why a lawyer and business consultant?
    • Focus areas of attorney Marian Härtel
      • Focus on start-ups
      • Investment advice
      • Corporate law
      • Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain and Games
      • AI and SaaS
      • Streamers and influencers
      • Games and esports law
      • IT/IP Law
      • Law firm for GMBH,UG, GbR
      • Law firm for IT/IP and media law
    • The everyday life of an IT lawyer
    • How can I help clients?
    • Testimonials
    • Team: Saskia Härtel – WHO AM I?
    • Agile and lean law firm
    • Price overview
    • Various information
      • Terms
      • Privacy policy
      • Imprint
  • Services
    • Support and advice of agencies
    • Contract review and preparation
    • Games law consulting
    • Consulting for influencers and streamers
    • Advice in e-commerce
    • DLT and Blockchain consulting
    • Legal advice in corporate law: from incorporation to structuring
    • Legal compliance and expert opinions
    • Outsourcing – for companies or law firms
    • Booking as speaker
  • News
    • Gloss / Opinion
    • Law on the Internet
    • Online retail
    • Law and computer games
    • Law and Esport
    • Blockchain and web law
    • Data protection Law
    • Copyright
    • Labour law
    • Competition law
    • Corporate
    • EU law
    • Law on the protection of minors
    • Tax
    • Other
    • Internally
  • Podcast
    • ITMediaLaw Podcast
  • Knowledge base
    • Laws
    • Legal terms
    • Contract types
    • Clause types
    • Forms of financing
    • Legal means
    • Authorities
    • Company forms
    • Tax
    • Concepts
  • Videos
    • Information videos – about Marian Härtel
    • Videos – about me (Couch)
    • Blogpost – individual videos
    • Videos on services
    • Shorts
    • Podcast format
    • Third-party videos
    • Other videos
  • Contact
Rechtsanwalt Marian Härtel - ITMediaLaw

ECJ for sale of “used” e-books

19. December 2019
in Copyright, Law on the Internet
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0 0
A A
0
20200427 Eugh Diskr o Person
Key Facts
  • The ECJ ruled that downloading e-books constitutes communication to the public.
  • NUV and GAU sued Tom Kabinet for copyright infringement of e-books.
  • Tom Kabinet argued that the exhaustion rule applies to e-books.
  • The Court declared that exhaustion is excluded for e-books.
  • Communication to the public includes any making available to absent users.
  • The number of simultaneous accesses is decisive for communication to the public.
  • The ruling is highly relevant for providers of further sales of digital products.

By today’s judgment, the Court of Justice has held that the release of an e-book for permanent use to the public by downloading falls within the concept of ‘communication to the public’ within the meaning of Directive 2001/291.

Content Hide
1. What is it all about?
2. The ECJ sees it differently
3. Conclusion
3.1. Author: Marian Härtel

What is it all about?

Nederlands Uitgeversverbond (NUV) and Groep Algemene Uitgevers (GAU), two associations whose aim is to represent the interests of Dutch publishers, brought an action before the Rechtbank Den Haag (Court of The Hague, Netherlands) and, inter alia, requested that the Company Tom Kabinet to prohibit members of the “reading club” he founded from making e-books available on his website or to reproduce these books.

NUV and GAU claim that these activities infringe the copyrights of their members in those e-books. By offering “used” e-books for sale in the context of this reading club, Tom Kabinet makes an unauthorised public representation of those books.

Tom Kabinet, on the other hand, submits that those activities are subject to the distribution right which is subject to a rule of exhaustion in that directive where the subject-matter in question, in the present case the e-books, is applied by the rightholder or by his consent were sold in the Union. That rule would mean that, following the sale of the e-books in question, NUV and GAU would no longer have the exclusive right to allow or prohibit their distribution to the public.

The ECJ sees it differently

The Court has held that the provision of an e-book for permanent use by downloading does not cover the right of ‘distribution to the public’ within the meaning of Article 4(4) of the Treaty. 1 of Directive 2001/29, but rather under that of Article 3(3) of the 1 of that directive, the right of ‘communication to the public’ falls, for which exhaustion is required under Article 3(3) of the Directive. 3 is excluded.

The Court based that finding, in particular, on the fact that it inferred from the copyright law of the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO), which was the basis of that directive, and the preparatory work for that directive, that the The EU legislature intended to reserve the exhaustion rule of the distribution of physical objects, such as books on a material carrier.

On the other hand, the application of the exhaustion rule to e-books could have a far greater impact on the interests of rightholders in obtaining an appropriate remuneration for their works than in the case of books on a material medium, since the non-physical digital copies of e-books do not deteriorate through use, and thus represent a perfect replacement for new copies in a possible second-hand market.

As far as the concept of ‘communication to the public’ is to be understood, the Court states in more detail that it must be understood in a broad sense, namely that it includes any communication to the public which does not take place at the place where the communication originates. and thus includes any appropriate wired or wireless public transmission or redistribution of a work. That concept combines two cumulative elements, namely an act of reproduction of a work and its communication to the public.

As regards the first feature, it is clear from the explanatory memorandum to the proposal for Directive 2001/29 that:

“the critical act is the making available of the work to the public, i.e. the offering of a work in a publicly accessible place, which precedes the stage of its actual ‘transmission on demand’

”
, and that it is

‘It is irrelevant whether a person has actually retrieved it or not’.

Therefore, in the Court’s view, making the works in question available to any person registering on the Reading Club’s website must be regarded as a ‘reproduction’ of a work, without it being necessary for the person concerned to have that by actually retrieving the e-book from this website.

As far as the second feature is concerned, account must be taken not only of how many persons can have access to the same work at the same time, but also of how many of them can have access to the work one after the other. In the present case, the Court considers that the number of persons who may have parallel or successive access to the same work via the reading club’s platform is significant. Thus, subject to an investigation by the referring court, the work in question must be regarded as reproduced in public, taking into account all the relevant circumstances.

Moreover, the Court has held that, in order to be classified as a communication to the public, it is necessary for a protected work to be classified using a technical procedure which differs from the ones previously used, or otherwise for a new it is reproduced to the public, i.e. to an audience which the copyright holders had not already thought of when they allowed the original communication to the public. Since, in the present case, the making available of an e-book is generally a licence to use the e-book, which only permits the reading of the e-book by the user who downloaded the e-book in question with his own device, it must be assumed that a Reproduction, as carried out by the company Tom Kabinet, is made for an audience that the copyright holders had not already thought of, i.e. for a new audience.

Conclusion

The ruling is likely to be highly relevant for many similar suppliers who want to resell or offer digital products.

Marian Härtel
Author: Marian Härtel

Marian Härtel ist Rechtsanwalt und Fachanwalt für IT-Recht mit einer über 25-jährigen Erfahrung als Unternehmer und Berater in den Bereichen Games, E-Sport, Blockchain, SaaS und Künstliche Intelligenz. Seine Beratungsschwerpunkte umfassen neben dem IT-Recht insbesondere das Urheberrecht, Medienrecht sowie Wettbewerbsrecht. Er betreut schwerpunktmäßig Start-ups, Agenturen und Influencer, die er in strategischen Fragen, komplexen Vertragsangelegenheiten sowie bei Investitionsprojekten begleitet. Dabei zeichnet sich seine Beratung durch einen interdisziplinären Ansatz aus, der juristische Expertise und langjährige unternehmerische Erfahrung miteinander verbindet. Ziel seiner Tätigkeit ist stets, Mandanten praxisorientierte Lösungen anzubieten und rechtlich fundierte Unterstützung bei der Umsetzung innovativer Geschäftsmodelle zu gewährleisten.

Tags: BankdigitalLawsuitLizenzUrheberrecht

Weitere spannende Blogposts

Legal action for banned Instagram accounts: Your options and precedents

Instagram blocking? Observe appropriate waiting period!
20. July 2023

If your Instagram account is suspended, there are a number of steps you can take to preserve your rights and...

Read moreDetails

BGH submits definition of “immaterial damage” under GDPR to ECJ

BGH submits definition of “immaterial damage” under GDPR to ECJ
10. November 2023

The VI. Civil Senate of the Federal Court of Justice referred questions to the Court of Justice of the European...

Read moreDetails

Computer Bild allowed to use photo of Jan Böhmermann

Computer Bild allowed to use photo of Jan Böhmermann
7. November 2022

The magazine Computer Bild was allowed to illustrate a text about DVB-T2 receivers in HD quality with a photo of...

Read moreDetails

Federal Court of Justice and “climate neutral”

BGH considers Uber Black to be anti-competitive
10. July 2024

The Federal Court of Justice has ruled that advertising with an ambiguous environmental term (here: "climate neutral") is only permissible...

Read moreDetails

Esport and the concept of sport – let it stay

Esport and the concept of sport - let it stay
21. February 2019

Yesterday the hearing took place in the sports committee of the Bundestag and with a few exceptions no one really...

Read moreDetails

Generative AI in contractual practice: transparency and legal aspects with a focus on exploitation rights clauses

Generative AI in contractual practice: transparency and legal aspects with a focus on exploitation rights clauses
17. January 2024

Introduction to the world of generative AI The rapid development of generative AI technologies has far-reaching implications for the creation...

Read moreDetails

Automatic renewal of online subscription to 30 times price invalid

Automatic renewal of online subscription to 30 times price invalid
7. November 2022

"Subscription traps" are out there all the time. But some seem particularly outlandish. A provider of such a service has...

Read moreDetails

Amazon can’t just freeze seller funds

Purchased reviews on Amazon
4. July 2019

The District Court of Hildesheim has put a stop to Amazon, by means of an injunction, forbidding its well-known practice...

Read moreDetails

Free initial assessment, via chat or audio

Free initial assessment, via chat or audio
7. November 2022

As you can see, with over 1000 articles in the last almost 3 years, I have definitely united a large...

Read moreDetails
So langsam nimmt der Shop Form an
Internally

So langsam nimmt der Shop Form an

3. July 2025

Mein neuer ITMediaLaw-Shop füllt sich stetig mit Inhalten und Angeboten – von praxisnahen E-Books über umfassende Bundle-Pakete bis hin zu...

Read moreDetails
Dark Patterns: UX-Tricks im Visier von Gesetzgeber und Gerichten

Dark Patterns: UX-Tricks im Visier von Gesetzgeber und Gerichten

2. July 2025
Altersverifikation im Internet: Pflichten für Anbieter in Deutschland und Europa

Altersverifikation im Internet: Pflichten für Anbieter in Deutschland und Europa

30. June 2025
KI-Training und Urheberrecht: US-Gericht setzt auf Fair Use – was bedeutet das für KI und was gilt in Deutschland?

KI-Training und Urheberrecht: US-Gericht setzt auf Fair Use – was bedeutet das für KI und was gilt in Deutschland?

26. June 2025
KI-Codetools und Open-Source-Lizenzen: Risiken für Entwickler

KI-Codetools und Open-Source-Lizenzen: Risiken für Entwickler

25. June 2025

Podcastfolge

Rechtskette beim Spieleentwickler

Rechtskette beim Spieleentwickler

19. April 2025

In dieser kurzen Episode diskutieren Anna und Max die Bedeutung der Rechtekette im Game Development – ein zentraler Aspekt für...

Read moreDetails
Rechtliche Herausforderungen innovativer Geschäftsmodelle

Rechtliche Herausforderungen innovativer Geschäftsmodelle

26. September 2024
Rechtliche Herausforderungen und Chancen durch KI-Influencer und virtuelle Mitarbeitende

Rechtliche Herausforderungen und Chancen durch KI-Influencer und virtuelle Mitarbeitende

19. April 2025
Der unkonventionelle Anwalt: Ein Nerd im Dienste des Rechts

Der unkonventionelle Anwalt: Ein Nerd im Dienste des Rechts

25. September 2024
Juristische Trends für Startups 2025: Chancen und Herausforderungen

Juristische Trends für Startups 2025: Chancen und Herausforderungen

19. April 2025

Video

Mein transparente Abrechnung

Mein transparente Abrechnung

10. February 2025

In diesem Video rede ich ein wenig über transparente Abrechnung und wie ich kommuniziere, was es kostet, wenn man mit...

Read moreDetails
Faszination zwischen und Recht und Technologie

Faszination zwischen und Recht und Technologie

10. February 2025
Meine zwei größten Herausforderungen sind?

Meine zwei größten Herausforderungen sind?

10. February 2025
Was mich wirklich freut

Was mich wirklich freut

10. February 2025
Was ich an meinem Job liebe!

Was ich an meinem Job liebe!

10. February 2025
  • Privacy policy
  • Imprint
  • Contact
  • About lawyer Marian Härtel
Marian Härtel, Rathenaustr. 58a, 14612 Falkensee, info@itmedialaw.com

Marian Härtel - Rechtsanwalt für IT-Recht, Medienrecht und Startups, mit einem Fokus auf innovative Geschäftsmodelle, Games, KI und Finanzierungsberatung.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
  • Informationen
    • Ideal partner
    • About lawyer Marian Härtel
    • Quick and flexible access
    • Principles as a lawyer
    • Why a lawyer and business consultant?
    • Focus areas of attorney Marian Härtel
      • Focus on start-ups
      • Investment advice
      • Corporate law
      • Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain and Games
      • AI and SaaS
      • Streamers and influencers
      • Games and esports law
      • IT/IP Law
      • Law firm for GMBH,UG, GbR
      • Law firm for IT/IP and media law
    • The everyday life of an IT lawyer
    • How can I help clients?
    • Testimonials
    • Team: Saskia Härtel – WHO AM I?
    • Agile and lean law firm
    • Price overview
    • Various information
      • Terms
      • Privacy policy
      • Imprint
  • Services
    • Support and advice of agencies
    • Contract review and preparation
    • Games law consulting
    • Consulting for influencers and streamers
    • Advice in e-commerce
    • DLT and Blockchain consulting
    • Legal advice in corporate law: from incorporation to structuring
    • Legal compliance and expert opinions
    • Outsourcing – for companies or law firms
    • Booking as speaker
  • News
    • Gloss / Opinion
    • Law on the Internet
    • Online retail
    • Law and computer games
    • Law and Esport
    • Blockchain and web law
    • Data protection Law
    • Copyright
    • Labour law
    • Competition law
    • Corporate
    • EU law
    • Law on the protection of minors
    • Tax
    • Other
    • Internally
  • Podcast
    • ITMediaLaw Podcast
  • Knowledge base
    • Laws
    • Legal terms
    • Contract types
    • Clause types
    • Forms of financing
    • Legal means
    • Authorities
    • Company forms
    • Tax
    • Concepts
  • Videos
    • Information videos – about Marian Härtel
    • Videos – about me (Couch)
    • Blogpost – individual videos
    • Videos on services
    • Shorts
    • Podcast format
    • Third-party videos
    • Other videos
  • Contact
  • en English
  • de Deutsch
Kostenlose Kurzberatung