Please note that all my articles are for informational purposes only and not legal advice. I assume no liability for the content of my articles. The articles may be out of date, the legal situation may have changed, or the specific situation in a case may need to be assessed differently. A binding consultation can only be given by me directly in the individual case. Take advantage of my free brief consultation!
EUGH: No second right of withdrawal if trial subscription turns into paid subscription!
A consumer has a single right to cancel a subscription taken out at a distance, which is initially free and is automatically renewed
The situation is different if the consumer was not adequately informed about the total cost of the subscription. The company Sofatutor operates Internet learning platforms for students. When taking out a subscription for the first time, it can be tested free of charge for 30 days and can be cancelled without notice at any time during this period. The subscription only becomes chargeable after these 30 days.
If the paid subscription period expires without cancellation, the subscription will be automatically renewed for a specified period.
In case of a distance contract conclusion, Sofatutor informs consumers about the right of withdrawal (right of revocation). However, the Association for Consumer Information (VKI) is of the opinion that the consumer is entitled to a right of withdrawal (right of cancellation) not only due to the conclusion of a 30-day free trial subscription, but also due to the conversion of this subscription into a paid subscription and its extension. The Supreme Court (Austria), which is hearing the case, asked the Court of Justice to interpret the Consumer Rights Directive1 in this regard.
The Court answers that, in principle, the consumer has the right to withdraw from a distance contract only once in the case of a subscription contract which initially provides for a free period and is automatically renewed if that contract is not terminated.
However, if the consumer was not clearly, understandably and explicitly informed at the time of subscription that this subscription would become chargeable after a free initial period, he must have a new right of withdrawal.
Marian Härtel is a lawyer and entrepreneur specializing in copyright law, competition law and IT/IP law, with a focus on games, esports, media and blockchain.
